VirFerrOx
Carbon Conundrum Confronts Crafty Clusters as CBAM Casts Crucial Constraints
Wednesday, July 9, 2025
Synopsis: -
A recent opinion by Manini of the Observer Research Foundation warns that the European Union’s Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism will severely impact India’s steel MSMEs. Despite temporary exemptions, these small players must quickly adopt decarbonised processes like scrap-based Electric Arc Furnaces & renewable energy to avoid exclusion from global markets and secure their place in green global trade.
Regulatory Riptide Reshapes Regional RecyclersAs the European Union’s Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism begins enforcement in January 2026, India’s micro, small & medium enterprises in the steel sector face mounting pressure. While enterprises exporting under 50 metric tons currently enjoy a brief exemption, this de minimis clause offers only transient relief. In reality, most MSMEs are deeply embedded in export supply chains, indirectly bound by CBAM’s mandates through larger Tier 1 suppliers targeting carbon-neutral compliance.
Embedded Emissions Erode Export EquanimityIn 2022, India’s export of iron, steel & cement totalled $31 billion, with nearly a quarter directed to the European Union. Within this matrix, MSMEs contribute significantly as Tier 2 or Tier 3 suppliers, especially in industrial hubs like Coimbatore, Mandi Gobindgarh & Rajkot. These clusters host hundreds of outdated, coal-reliant rolling mills. Although many stay below the 50-ton threshold individually, when bundled through aggregators or merchant exporters, they exceed the cap, exposing them to CBAM’s carbon cost.
Decarbonisation Disparities Divide Dominant & DispersedIndia’s large steelmakers are proactively investing in hydrogen technologies, renewable power & emissions reporting. In contrast, MSMEs struggle with scarce capital, limited awareness & outdated infrastructure. The carbon accountability adopted by Tier 1 exporters exerts trickle-down pressure, compelling their smaller suppliers to comply or risk marginalisation. As the EU revisits the exemption post-2026, the noose may tighten further, formalising what global buyers are already enforcing through voluntary green standards.
Furnace Futility Fuels Fossil-Heavy FootprintsThe steel sector’s secondary route, using Electric Arc Furnace or Induction Furnace, produces over 50% of national output. Yet much of this relies on coal-based Direct Reduced Iron, a method incongruent with decarbonisation. More than 1,200 small-scale steel re-rolling mills generate 33 million metric tons annually, employing 400,000 workers. Without affordable clean alternatives, these facilities risk becoming non-compliant under emerging global trade frameworks.
Scrap Sufficiency Supports Sustainable Steel ScenariosA realistic solution lies in widespread adoption of scrap-based Electric Arc Furnaces powered by renewable electricity. These modular units emit 60% less carbon compared to blast furnaces. Many MSMEs already function in scrap-rich environments, but sourcing quality scrap remains a barrier. India relies heavily on scrap imports from the United States, United Kingdom & UAE. As exporting countries tighten norms to secure their own green transition, Indian firms face supply volatility.
Clustered Cleanliness Catalyses Carbon-Conscious ChangeEmbedding modular Electric Arc Furnaces within industrial clusters may bridge the transition gap. These shared low-capital, renewable-powered units offer scalable alternatives to expensive retrofits or capture technologies. When integrated with green hydrogen in the long term, they enable inclusive industrial decarbonisation. This empowers MSMEs to become proactive participants rather than passive recipients in the green value chain.
Pathway Parity Promotes Policy Precision for ProgressIndia’s decarbonisation policy must acknowledge the diversity of its steel producers. A one-size-fits-all framework overlooks the realities of MSMEs. Crafting decentralised, low-emission production models tailored to local contexts is essential. The upcoming National Green Hydrogen Mission and scrap policy reforms must prioritise enabling infrastructure, skill-building & financing mechanisms for small enterprises.
Economic Exclusion Echoes Environmental Evasion ErrorsCBAM is not merely a regulatory development, it signals a fundamental shift in global trade where carbon costs dictate market access. If India’s 300 million metric ton steel production target for 2030 is to be met alongside climate goals, MSMEs must be brought to the forefront. Ignoring their challenges may not only fracture the domestic industry but also risk long-term trade irrelevance.
Key Takeaways:
CBAM enforcement from 2026 will push India’s MSMEs in the steel sector to decarbonise or risk exclusion from EU-linked supply chains.
Most MSMEs remain coal-reliant, but modular Electric Arc Furnaces powered by renewable energy offer a viable, low-capex transition path.
Without tailored policy support, Indian MSMEs risk economic marginalisation as green trade norms become mainstream globally.

Image Source : Content Factory